When Russell Wilson, quarterback of the New York Giants was told he’d be benched in favor of rookie Jaxson Dart, the franchise’s day‑to‑day narrative shifted dramatically. The decision came on September 24, 2025, just hours before the Giants’ Week 4 clash with the Los Angeles Chargers at MetLife Stadium, East Rutherford, New Jersey.
Key Facts
- Wilson signed a one‑year, $10.5 million deal on March 15, 2025, with incentives up to $21 million.
- Dart, the 25th overall pick from Ole Miss, made his first start in Week 4.
- The Giants entered the benching with a 0‑3 record and a 1‑4 slate after Week 5.
- Trade deadline: November 4, 2025; Wilson’s base salary is $2 million.
- Co‑owners John Mara and Steve Tisch remain publicly supportive of the youth movement.
Background: Wilson’s Return to New York
After two lackluster stints with Denver and Pittsburgh, Wilson arrived in New York with a reputation for clutch performances—and a Super Bowl XLVIII ring from his Seattle days. The one‑year pact, inked on March 15, 2025, seemed like a low‑risk gamble for a team desperate to find a steady veteran presence.
Coach Brian Daboll, who announced Wilson as the starter on July 23, 2025, said the veteran’s leadership would help bridge the gap until the rookie class matured. Little did anyone suspect that three games later the bridge would be torn down.
Three‑Game Struggle and Benching Decision
Week 1 against the Philadelphia Eagles, Week 2 at the Dallas Cowboys, and Week 3 versus the Kansas City Chiefs produced a combined passer rating of 65.5. Wilson completed under 60 % of his throws in two of those outings, threw zero touchdowns, and was intercepted twice in the Chiefs loss. The Giants managed touchdowns on just three of ten red‑zone trips.
Fans at MetLife Stadium even started chanting “We want Dart” during the Chiefs game—a clear signal that patience was wearing thin. According to SI.com’s Gilberto Manzano, Wilson’s signing quickly slipped onto his “worst free‑agent signings of 2025” list.
Jaxson Dart Takes the Helm
The rookie’s first start came during Giants vs Los Angeles ChargersMetLife Stadium. Dart threw for 215 yards, two touchdowns, and one interception— numbers that mirrored his college career at Ole Miss.
That win lifted the Giants to 1‑3, but a 26‑14 defeat at the Caesars Superdome against the New Orleans Saints in Week 5 sent the record to 1‑4. Pro Football Network’s analyst Mike Renner noted Dart’s completion rate hovered around 60 %, “decent” for a rookie, but the interception ratio was “higher than acceptable.”
Reactions: Players, Fans, and Front Office
At a press conference on September 24, Wilson, visibly calm, said, “I know that I’m going to respond in the right way every day,” and added, “I’m not done.” He also promised to mentor Dart, framing the benching as a “coach’s decision, not a personal one.”
His wife, Grammy‑nominated singer Ciara Wilson, featured in a heartfelt Instagram post captioned “My why! Love you guys.” The post quickly racked up over 200,000 likes, showing the human side of the saga.
General manager Joe Schoen faced a flurry of criticism for the $18.5 million combined spend on Wilson and former Pro Bowler Jameis Winston. Analysts argue that the money might have been better allocated to the offensive line or defensive secondary.
Trade Rumors and What Lies Ahead
NFL Network’s salary‑cap analyst Joel Corry said Wilson is a “cheap, veteran option” for any team in need before the November 4 trade deadline. The Atlanta Falcons, with backup Kirk Cousins, are reportedly the most interested party.
If a trade materializes, the Giants would likely keep Winston as the primary backup, solidifying a three‑quarterback depth chart that includes a rookie, a veteran, and a seasoned journeyman. Coach Daboll hinted that the team’s focus now is “building around Dart while staying competitive.”
Meanwhile, the Giants are preparing for a Week 6 showdown against the Philadelphia Eagles at Lincoln Financial Field. With a 1‑4 record, every snap will be under scrutiny.
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Russell Wilson’s benching affect the Giants’ playoff chances?
With a 1‑4 start, the Giants are already on the outside edge of playoff contention. Benchings signal a shift toward rebuilding, but a surprise surge from Jaxson Dart could keep them alive. Statistically, teams that replace a starter after three losses win only 30 % of the remaining games, so the odds are slim.
What are the financial implications of trading Wilson before the deadline?
Wilson’s contract carries an $8 million signing bonus already paid, leaving a $2 million base salary. Any trade partner would assume that base plus a small portion of his incentives, making him a cost‑effective veteran. The Giants could also free up cap space to address other weak positions.
Why did the Giants choose Jaxson Dart over a more experienced backup?
Dart was the 25th overall pick, seen as the franchise quarterback of the future. Owner John Mara has publicly stated the organization wants to “build around youth.” The team also believes his arm strength and mobility better suit the modern NFL’s passing attack than Winston’s more pocket‑oriented style.
Will Wilson serve as a mentor despite being traded?
Wilson’s comments at the September 24 press conference emphasized mentorship, and his veteran status makes him a valuable practice‑field leader. Even if he lands with another team, his willingness to guide younger QBs could make him an attractive trade chip for clubs looking to blend experience with development.
What does this mean for Jameis Winston’s role on the Giants?
Winston is expected to slide into the backup role behind Dart. His experience could prove crucial if the rookie struggles, and the team may leverage Winston’s leadership in the locker room while preserving his contract for strategic depth.